Here's a more positive review of Dave. Thanks to P.D. Fitzgerald for sending it in.
From: Newark Star-Ledger
By Alan Sepinwall...Paul McCrane, whose smarmy Dr. "Rocket" Romano was about the only reason to watch in many episodes in the past two years, got promoted to full-time status this year, at which point his screen time plummeted. The jerk quotient has been mostly filled by newcomer Erik Palladino, as an annoying yet likable resident who prefers to be called "Dr. Dave". While many of the original characters seem played out -- which, to be fair, is all but inevitable in this sixth season -- they all come to life when paired with Dr. Dave...